5419 East Oak Island Drive, Oak Island, NC 28465 (910) 477-4161
5419 East Oak Island Drive, Oak Island, NC 28465 (910) 477-4161
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

  • a close up of a sandwich on a plate
    a close up of a sandwich on a plate
    Slide 1 of 2
  • a close up of a sandwich sitting on top of a wooden table
    a close up of a sandwich sitting on top of a wooden table
    Slide 2 of 2

    • Start here

    Please let your server or bartender know of any food allergies. Some items are served raw or undercooked, or contain (may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. No substitutions. 20% gratuity automatically added to parties of 6 or more.

    Starters

    • Paul's Island Sampler

      4 wings, Paul's wicked pickles, and garlic cheese curds with ranch

      $16

    • Tuna Stackable

      Cajun seared tuna, spring mix, teriyaki glaze, scallions, toasted pita, and cucumber wasabi for dipping

      $18

    • Cajun Fish Bites

      Fried mahi bites breaded with Cajun seasoning served with horseradish mayo

      $13

    • Paul’s Wicked Pickles

      Pickle chips brined in our house-made Carolina Reaper sauce, lightly fried, and served with a side of ranch (our Reaper sauce is no joke—these are spicy!).

      $9

      hot, gluten free, vegetarian

    • Garlic Cheese Curds

      Cheese curds served with ranch

      $11

    • Fried Clams

      Fried clams on a bed of spring mix served with cocktail sauce and lemon (tartar sauce on request)

      1/2 lb for $11

      1 lb for $20

    • Pinch + Eat Shrimp

      Semi-peeled shrimp tossed in Chesapeake Bay seasoning served with cocktail sauce and melted butter

      1/2 lb for $10

      1 lb for $18

      gluten free

    Soups & Salads

    • Tomato Soup

      Our classic tomato soup is back!

      $8

      Pair it with a grilled cheese sandwich with American cheese (upcharge for cheese substitution) $5

      vegetarian

    • Taco Salad

      Lettuce, seasoned ground beef, black beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, cilantro vinaigrette, and shredded cheese in a tortilla bowl

      $16

    • Chef Ron's Wedge

      Iceberg lettuce, hard-boiled eggs, crispy shallots, bacon, parmesan, blue cheese dressing, and croutons

      $14

    • Beet and Goat Cheese Salad

      Beets, candied walnuts, spring mix, goat cheese with an orange balsamic vinaigrette

      $14

      vegetarian

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

      Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing

      $18

    • Wings

      Fried wings tossed with your choice of sauce

      6 for $12

      12 for $23

      gluten free

    • Fried Ribs

      Fried ribs tossed with your choice of sauce

      $15

      gluten free

    Sauces

    One per order of six wings or order of fried ribs, +1 extra for each additional sauce.

    • Buffalo

      The classic, done properly

      mild, gluten free, vegetarian

    • Atomic Carolina Reaper

      Our already intense Carolina Reaper sauce + fresh chilies and powders *this sauce is seriously no joke*

      hot, vegetarian

    • Cheerwine BBQ Sauce

      Cheerwine, BBQ sauce

      gluten free, vegetarian

    • Spicy Lemon Pepper

      Our popular buffalo sauce mixed with our lemon pepper dry rub

      mild, gluten free, vegetarian

    • Thai Hot Honey Sauce

      Thai pepper, honey, habanero

      mild, gluten free, vegetarian

    VegetarianGluten FreeSpicy

    a plate of food sitting on top of a wooden table
    a plate of food sitting on top of a wooden table

    Burger/Handhelds

    Comes with fries.

    Please let your server or bartender know of any food allergies. Some items are served raw or undercooked, or contain (may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. No substitutions. 20% gratuity automatically added to parties of 6 or more.

    Paul's Signature Double Smash Burger

    Double smash with fried onions, cheddar cheese, cheerwine BBQ sauce, lettuce, tomato, and onion on sourdough bread

    • Double

      $21

    • Single

      $16

    Set Options

    • All the Way

      Slaw, chili, onions, American cheese, King’s Hawaiian bun

      Double $21

      Single $16

    • Black & Bleu

      Blackened with bleu cheese, King's Hawaiian bun

      Double $21

      Single $16

    • Mushroom Swiss

      Mushroom and Swiss, King's Hawaiian bun

      Double $21

      Single $16

    • Backyard Classic

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese, and mayonnaise, King's Hawaiian bun

      Double $21

      Single $16

    • Firehouse

      Pepper Jack & candied jalapenos, King's Hawaiian bun

      Double $21

      Single $16

      spicy

    • Impossible Smash Burger

      Starter plant-based smash burger on a King’s Hawaiian bun. Build it your way

      Double $23

      Single $18

    • Build Your Own

      Starter smash burger on a King's Hawaiian bun. Build it your way

      Double $21

      Single $16

    • Add Ons

      Lettuce

      Tomato

      Onion (raw)

      Pickles

      Mayo

      Onion (caramelized) $1

      Candied Jalapenos $1

      Mushrooms $1

      Chili $2

      Thick cut bacon $2

      Gluten free bun $2

      American

      Cheddar $1

      Pepper jack $1

      Provolone $1

      Swiss $1

    VegetarianGluten FreeSpicy

    Handhelds

    Comes with fries

    • Patty Melt

      Grilled ground beef, house-made Thousand Island dressing, caramelized onions, and Swiss cheese on toasted sourdough bread

      $17

    • Shrimp Quesadilla

      Grilled shrimp, shredded cheddar cheese on toasted tortilla served with pineapple salsa and cilantro sour cream

      $15

    • Mediterranean Steak Wrap

      Tender steak, rice, tomatoes, smoked feta, black olives, and tzatziki sauce in a toasted wrap

      $16

    • Smash Sausage

      Sausage, over-easy egg, and American cheese

      $15

    • Mahi Sandwich

      Blackened mahi served with lettuce, tomato, and onion

      $18

    • Chicken Sandwich

      Boneless thighs, fried or grilled. Choose a set option or build your own!

      $16

    • Hot Dogs

      All-beef hot dogs (2). Choose a set option or build your own!

      $12

    • BLT

      Thick-cut bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on white bread

      $13

    a plate of hot dogs sitting on a table
    a plate of hot dogs sitting on a table

    House Favorites

    Please let your server or bartender know of any food allergies. Some items are served raw or undercooked, or contain (may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. No substitutions. 20% gratuity automatically added to parties of 6 or more.

    • Calabash Platter

      Flounder, shrimp, and clam strips battered and fried, served with tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, fries, white slaw, and lemon wedge

      $29

    • Popcorn Shrimp Platter

      Shrimp battered and fried served with tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, fries, white slaw, and lemon wedge

      $19

    • Cajun Chicken Pasta

      Cajun chicken over tortellini tossed in a rich cream sauce and served with bread

      $20

    • Fish and Chips

      Beer-battered cod with tartar sauce served with fries, white slaw, and lemon wedge

      $19

    VegetarianGluten FreeSpicy

    a plate of food on a table
    a plate of food on a table

    Sides and More

    Please let your server or bartender know of any food allergies. Some items are served raw or undercooked, or contain (may contain) raw or undercooked ingredients. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. No substitutions. 20% gratuity automatically added to parties of 6 or more.

    Sides

    • White Slaw

      Cabbage, mayo, apple cider vinegar

      $4

      gluten free, vegetarian

    • French Fries

      Seasoned crinkle cut fries

      $4

      gluten free

    • Seasoned Rice

      Italian seasoning, butter, S & P

      $4

      vegetarian

    • Side Salad

      Spring mix, red onion, grape tomato, cucumber, carrot, croutons, and your choice of dressing

      $5

      vegetarian

    • Esquites

      Grilled corn topped with shaved cotija cheese, garlic aioli, cilantro, paprika, and green onion

      $5

      gluten free

    • Collard Greens

      Southern style with bacon

      $5

    VegetarianGluten FreeSpicy

    Sweet Finishes

    • Dessert Trio

      A trio of induglence—slices of limoncello cake, banana coconut cake, and NY turtle cheesecake finished with whipped cream

      $21

    • Dense Chocolate Cake

      A slice of dark, moist chocolate cake layered with smooth chocolate filling, serves 2 people

      $15

    • New York Turtle Cheesecake

      With caramel sauce

      $8

    • Limoncello Cake

      With raspberry sauce

      $8

    • Banana Coconut Cake

      $8

      gluten free

    a piece of chocolate cake on a plate
    a piece of chocolate cake on a plate

    Non-Alcoholic/THC

    Non-Alcoholic

    • Athletic - Upside Down, <.5%, Golden Ale, CT, 12 Oz

      Non-alcoholic Golden Ale is pale orange in color with aromas and flavors of cereal grain, banana, and lemon

      $5

    • Heineken 0.0, HOL, 11.2 oz

      Perfectly balanced taste with refreshing fruity note

      $5

    • Mich Ultra, 0.0%, MO, 12 Oz

      $5

    • Paul’s Island Palmer

      Black tea, lemon, lavender

      $8

    THC Drinks

    • Cycling Frog

      Grapefruit or Wild Cherry, 5mg THC/10mg CBD, OR, 12oz 8
      Black Currant, 10mg THC/10mg CBD, OR, 12oz 10

    • Asheville Dispensary

      Tahitian Lime, 5mg THC/5mg CBD, NC, 12oz

      $8

    • Dayzed

      Fruit Punch, 5mg THC/5mg CBD, NC, 12oz

      $8

    • Cümulo

      Pink Lemonade, 5mg THC/10mg CBD, NC, 12oz 8
      Mango Lime, 10mg THC/20mg CBD, NC, 12oz 10

    • Foundry Nation

      Two Scoops – Root Beer Float, Cherry Cream Float, or Orange Dream Float, 10mg THC, MN, 12oz

      $10

    Soft Drinks

    • Water

    • Sweet Tea

    • Unsweet Tea

    • Coke

    • Coke Zero

    • Diet Coke

    • Mello-Yello

    • Mr. Pibb

    • Pink Lemonade

    • Sprite

    • Ginger Ale

    • Lemonade

    • Red Bull

    • Sugar Free Red Bull

    • Tropical Red Bull

    • Watermelon Red Bull

    • Coconut Berry Red Bull

    VegetarianGluten FreeSpicy

    Alcoholic Beverages

    Paul’s of Oak Island is the first bar in the state of North Carolina to be approved for whiskey on tap.

    Signature Cocktails

    • Margarita

      Esoplon tequila, lime, simple syrup (1:1), salted rim, lime

      $12

    • Orange Crush

      Deep Eddy orange vodka, triple sec, OJ, splash of Sprite, orange half wheel

      $12

    • Long Island Iced Tea

      Available on Tap! The classic done properly!

      $12

    • Cherry Bomb

      Deep eddy lime, coconut rum, Sprite, and grenadine, garnished with lime and cherry

      $12

    Draft Beverages

    All draft beers are 16 oz

    Ales & Lagers

    • Birdsong-Rewind, 4.0%, Pilsner, NC (#7)

      $6

    • Fullsteam-Paycheck, 4.5%, Pilsner, NC (#9)

      $6

    • Stella Artois, 5.0%, Lager, MO (#2)

      $6

    • Red Oak-Bavarian Amber, 5%, Lager, NC (#8)

      $5

    • R&d-Storm Brew, 4.2%, Lager, NC 5 (#4)

      $5

    • Busch Light, 4.1%, Light Lager, MO (#6)

      $5

    • Michelob Ultra, 4.2%, Light Lager, CO (#13)

      $5

    • Margaritaville-Landshark, 4.6%, Lager, MO (#14)

      $5

    • Narragansett-Lager, 5%, Lager, RI (#16)

      $5

    • Kona-Big Wave, 4.4%, Golden Ale, HI (#17)

      $5

    India Pale Ales

    • Legion-Juicy Jay, 6.3%, Neipa, NC (#11)

      $7

    • R&d-7 Saturdays, 6.2%, IPA, NC (#12)

      $7

    • Wicked Weed-Pernicious, 7.3%, IPA, NC (#15)

      $7

    Wheat

    • Golden Road-Mango Cart, 4%, Wheat, CA (#5)

      $5

    • Allagash-White, 5.2%, Witbier, ME (#20)

      $6

    Specialty Draft

    THC

    • Five Flowers-Rose Lemonade, 5 Mg THC/5 Mg Cbd, NC. (#18)

      $7

    Wine

    • Winestream-Draft Prosecco (#21)

      $8

    • Carletto-Pinot Grigio (#22)

      $8

    Spirits

    • Whiskey on Draft! (#23)

      1 oz pour $6

      2 oz pour $12

    • Long Island Iced Tea (#24)

      $11

    Stouts/Brown Ales

    • Left Hand-Peanut Butter Milk Stout, 6.0%, Milk Stout (nitro), CO (#1)

      $6

    • Birdsong-Lazy Bird Brown, 5.5%, Brown, NC (#19)

      $5

    Ciders

    • Blake’s-Triple Jam, 6.5%, Hard Cider, MI (#3)

      $7

    • Bold Rock-Carolina Apple, 4.7%, Hard Cider, NC (#10)

      $6

    Macros

    *‘Dressed’ add lime, hot sauce & cajun seasoning

    • Budweiser

      $4

    • Bud Lite

      $4

    • Busch Light

      $4

    • Coors Light

      $4

    • Corona

      $4

    • Michelob Ultra

      $4

    • Miller Lite

      $4

    • Natural Light

      $4

    • Pabst Blue Ribbon

      $4

    • Tecate*

      $4

    Frozen Cocktails

    • Strawberry Daiquiri

      $11

    • Watermelon Smash

      $11

    • Piña Colada

      $11

    • Banana Colada

      $11

    • Strawberry Banana Daiquiri

      $12

    • Miami Vice

      $12

    Packaged Beverages

    Ales & Lagers

    • Abita Strawberry, 4.2%, Lager, La, 12 Oz

      $6

    • Abita Purple Haze, 4.2%, Lager, La, 12 Oz

      $5

    • Birdsong-Jalapeno Pale Ale, 5.5%, Nc, 16 Oz

      $7

    • Blue Moon Belgian White, 5.4%, Wheat, Co, 12 Oz

      $4

    • Carolina Brewery-Sky Blue, 4.8%, Kolsch, Nc, 12 Oz

      $5

    • Flying Machine Dreamy Eyes, 5.1%, Ale, Nc, 16 Oz

      $7

    • Green's-Dry Hopped Lager, 4.1%, Lager, Ga, 12 Oz

      $7

      gluten free

    • Green's-Amber, 6.0%, Amber, Ga, 12 Oz

      $7

      gluten free

    • Robinsons Trooper Original, 4.7%, Ale, Eng, 16 Oz

      $8

    • Tarboro-Oh Hef Yeah, 4.3%, Hefeweizen, Nc, 16 Oz

      $6

    • Waterline-Kadala, 5.3 %, Pilsner, Nc, 16 Oz

      $6

    • Waterline-Kolsch, 5.3%, Kolsch, Nc, 12 Oz

      $5

    Sours

    • Broomtail - Galloping Gose, 5%, Sour, Nc, 16 Oz

      $7

    Ciders

    • Angry Orchard Hard Cider, Gf, 5%, Ny, 12 Oz

      $5

      gluten free

    • Blake’s-Original, 5.5%, Hard Cider, Mi, 12 Oz

      $5

    Hard Seltzers

    • Mighty Swell, 5.0%, Nc, 12 Oz

      $5

      gluten free

    • White Claw, 5.0%, Az, 12 Oz

      $5

      gluten free

    India Pale Ales

    • Birdsong-Hazy Sexy Cool, 6.8%, Neipa, Nc, 12 Oz

      $7

    • Founder's-All Day Ipa, 4.7%, Session Ipa, Mi, 12 Oz

      $5

    • Lagunitas-Ipa, 6.2%, Ca, 12 Oz

      $5

    • Wicked Weed-Perni-Haze, 6.9%, Hazy Ipa, Nc, 12 Oz

      $5

    VegetarianGluten FreeSpicy

    Wines

    All of our bottles of wine are available to go

    Whites

    • Winestream

      Draft Prosecco, 11.5%, IT

      Glass $8

    • Carletto

      Pinot Grigio, 14%, IT

      Glass $8

    • Ca' Bolani

      Pinot Grigio, 13.0%, IT

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    • Hess Shirtail

      Chardonnay, 13.5%, CA

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    • Las Campanas

      Rosé, 13%, ES

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    • Overstone

      Sauvignon Blanc, 13.0%, NZ 8 glass • 32 bottle

    Reds

    • Maison Nicolas

      Pinot Noir, 13.5%, CA

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    • Piattelli

      Malbec, 14.5%, ARG

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    • Match Book

      Cab. Sauvignon, 14.5%, CA

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    • Cypress Vineyards

      Cab. Sauvignon, 14.0%, CA

      Glass $8

      Bottle $32

    a close up of a beverage on a table
    a close up of a beverage on a table

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.